Herbert W. Simons
Emeritus Professor of Communication, Temple University
HOME VITA SELECTED WRITINGS MORE WRITINGS COURSE MATERIALS GUEST LECTURING MEDIA COMMENTARY EDUCATIONAL CONSULTING DIRECTOR, NCA FORUM LINKS
 

Excerpt H

[Following a mostly comic interlude about the behavior of Laura's cat]

Laura: Frank, are you maintaining that it wasn't unethical?

Frank: I'm maintaining that it was...

Jean: Borderline?

Frank: I'll tell you something. If it were done to me in similar circumstances, I would not be pissed.

Dave: I agree with that. You wouldn't be.

Frank: If you did it to me; if Dave did it to me; if Jean did it to me.... If, on the other hand, someone I didn't know well did it to me, I would be very pissed and that's what's so disturbing about all of this--that you're sort of applying standards as if I'm a stranger.

Laura: No

Dave: Laura wouldn't do it to you, though.

Laura: I wouldn't do it to you.

Frank: But if you did it to me, I wouldn't mind.

Laura: But I wouldn't, Lou.

Dave: See, there are two parts to the "Do unto others." One would say there're one, but there're really two: "Do unto others as others would have done unto you." What does that mean? Well, it could mean, "Do to others what you'd find acceptable if done to you." Another one is "Do unto others what the other would do. And they really are two different things.

Frank: Or the third, "Do unto others as you would like them to do unto you." Which is really what it means.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction

A Reconstructive Rhetoric

Rhetoric and Rationality

Narrative

Dialogue and Friendship

An Analysis of a Taped Conversation About a Taped Conversation

Excerpt A
Commentary on
Excerpt A


Excerpt B
Commentary on
Excerpt B


Excerpt C
Commentary on
Excerpt C


Excerpt D
Commentary on
Excerpt D


Excerpt E
Commentary on
Excerpt E


Excerpt F
Commentary on
Excerpt F


Excerpt G
Commentary on
Excerpt G


Excerpt H
Commentary on
Excerpt H


Excerpt I
Commentary on
Excerpt I


Excerpt J
Commentary on
Excerpt J


Conclusion

References
SELECTED WRITINGS
A Dilemma-Centered Analysis of Clinton's August 17th Apologia: Implications for Rhetorical Theory and Method

Judging A Policy Proposal By the Company It Keeps: The Gore-Perot NAFTA Debate

Rhetoric of Inquiry as an Intellectual Movement

Arguing About the Ethos of Past Actions: An Analysis of a Taped Conversation About a Taped Conversation

Burke, Marx, and Warrantable Outrage

Rhetorical Hermeneutics and the Project of Globalization

Media & Politics

The Rhetorical Construction of Institutional Fact: An Analysis of Social Problems Discourse

Temple Issues Forum: Innovations in Pedagogy

The Rhetoric of Philosophical Incommensurability

Rhetoric of the Classroom Teacher

Going Meta

The RPS Approach

Social Movements